A Christmas Prince Film Review

A Christmas Prince Review: So mediocre it took a full year to write this

Last Christmas I watched A Christmas Prince on Netflix, intending to write one of my famously discerning Christmas film reviews. Unfortunately, shortly after I drafted this, Facebook demonetised my page and I was so done with the whole business that I abandoned Christmas film reviewing altogether. Which is a shame, because I’d already sat through this particular festive offering, and frankly, somebody ought to suffer for it besides me.

So here we are, almost a year later, and I’ve decided that my opinions about a mediocre Christmas film are far too important to be lost to history. WE’RE BACK, BABY.

A Christmas Prince is a Netflix original romantic comedy from 2017 which was somehow popular enough to warrant not one but TWO sequels. Having watched it, I cannot fathom why.

If you HATE reading, you can listen to me reading this below. Sorry for the mistakes, I’m not a natural.

A Christmas Prince film review

A Christmas Prince (2017): Film information

Starring: Rose McIver, Ben Lamb, Alice Krige, Honor Kneafsey, Sarah Douglas and Theo Devaney
Director: Alex Zamm
Released: 2017
Genre: Christmas romantic “comedy”
Running time: 92 long old minutes

Synopsis: An aspiring American journalist travels to the fictional European kingdom of Aldovia to investigate a reluctant prince, accidentally becomes his younger sister’s tutor and falls in love with him. Think The Princess Diaries, but with considerably worse journalism and a heroine who probably ought to be arrested.

Where to watch A Christmas Prince in the UK: As of November 2026, A Christmas Prince is available on Netflix. Streaming availability changes, so check JustWatch for the latest options.

A Christmas Prince: The plot (such as it is)

Our heroine is Amber, a Big City Girl and aspiring journalist working as a junior editor at a New York magazine, desperately seeking her big break. Her opportunity comes when she’s sent to Aldovia, a fictional European kingdom where Prince Richard is supposed to be taking the throne following the death of his father, but has gone suspiciously quiet about the whole business.

Richard has a reputation as an irresponsible playboy, although this seems to be based on absolutely nothing whatsoever except he’s a bit hairy (but sadly, only to start with). We never actually see him doing anything particularly playboyish. No shagging, no drugs, no shitting on anyone’s lawn. Disappointing really.

A Christmas Prince Film Review: It was shit

Amber arrives for a press conference but it’s cancelled at the last minute, leaving the assembled journalists rather cross; they travelled to a make-believe country for this! In this situation, a normal reporter might arrange an interview, contact the palace press office or perhaps investigate why the prince is refusing to become king.

Amber, however, has a much better idea.

She sneaks into the palace, where she’s obviously mistaken for the new American tutor to Princess Emily, Richard’s younger sister, and rather than explaining that there’s been a misunderstanding, she rolls with it. I’ve always said the best way to launch your journalism career is to impersonate a qualified professional and gain access to a royal family’s private quarters under false pretences.

Worryingly, nobody checks her identity, qualifications or references. Within minutes, Amber has destroyed an extremely expensive vase, and later she manages to damage a valuable painting. Despite being both a fraud and a walking insurance claim, she’s allowed to remain in the palace, where everyone gradually comes to adore her.

Amber: The world’s worst journalist

I need to talk about Amber’s career, because I am fairly baffled.

We’re told she’s a junior editor who dreams of becoming a proper journalist, which at least explains why she has absolutely no idea how it works – but you’d think she would have studied it or something. Her notes are less investigative reporting and more the private diary of an angsty blogger who has watched far too many Christmas films (ask me how I know). She wanders around the palace gazing meaningfully at things, writing down her feelings and occasionally looking troubled because she’s developed a crush on the man she’s supposed to be investigating.

Amber's notes
Amber’s notes. Fuck me.

She’s not doing something groundbreaking, like reporting on a constitutional crisis; she’s essentially writing a BuzzFeed article entitled I Went Undercover in a Royal Palace (You Won’t Believe What Happened Next!).

I think the film wants us to see Amber as a plucky, ambitious young woman who’ll stop at nothing to get her story, but what we’re actually watching is someone who has abandoned every principle of journalism before she’s even written her first article. She doesn’t investigate so much as lurk, and her professional judgement deteriorates in direct proportion to the amount of time she spends looking at Richard in a jumper.

And of course, because this is a Christmas film, we’re supposed to find all this charming.

Is Amber the worst journalist ever in A Christmas Prince?

Prince Richard: Handsome, wealthy and super super dull

Meanwhile, Prince Richard turns out to be lovely, which is rather disappointing given that we’ve been promised an irresponsible playboy. He’s kind to his little sister, concerned about the people of Aldovia and generally behaves like a man who would never leave the toilet seat up.

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with him, which is basically the problem. He has no interesting flaws, no particular character development and very little personality beyond being a decent chap in knitwear. Boooooring.

Amber, naturally, falls hopelessly in love with him, although I’m not entirely sure why. They spend some time together, exchange a few weird gazes and suddenly we’re supposed to believe they’ve developed a relationship worth abandoning your career and moving to a fictional European country for. Their chemistry is about what you’d expect between two strangers waiting for a bus, but the film has decided they’re in love, so that’s that.

A Christmas Prince Review: So mediocre it took a full year to write this

It’s also worth remembering that Richard has no idea who Amber really is. As far as he’s concerned, she’s a tutor who has formed a lovely relationship with his little sister, rather than a journalist secretly investigating his family while making inappropriate notes about him.

I’m not sure this is the foundation of a healthy relationship, but then I’m not a Netflix screenwriter (yet. Come on guys! Give me a chance).

The Royal Family’s security arrangements get even worse

As Amber settles into palace life, she becomes involved in the family’s private affairs, particularly those of Princess Emily, who initially enjoys making life difficult for her tutors but – surprise surprise – eventually warms to Amber. The film treats their developing friendship as evidence that Amber is a wonderful person, rather than someone who has successfully deceived a child for professional gain and presumably really screwed up the life of the original, real tutor – who’s now spending Christmas without a job.

Then – plot twist! – while poking around in places she has absolutely no business being, Amber discovers Richard was adopted.

Under Aldovian law, this means he isn’t eligible to inherit the throne! You’d think this might have come up at some point during the previous few decades, but nobody in the royal household seems to have thought to check the rules of succession.

Perhaps she’ll realise that she’s obtained deeply personal information through deception, that Richard’s parentage is none of her business and that publishing it could have devastating consequences for a family who have welcomed her into their home?

No. She considers using it for her article and even discusses it with her friends back in New York.

I’m sorry, but what the actual fuck?

She’s lied her way into someone’s home, impersonated a tutor, befriended his younger sister just to get in his pants, destroyed several priceless antiques and is now contemplating exposing a deeply personal family secret to the entire world for lols. And somehow we are still expected to see her as the good guy.

At this point, any remaining sympathy I had for Amber packed its bags and left Aldovia.

Every Christmas film needs an evil cousin

Of course, no royal Christmas romance would be complete without a scheming relative who wants the throne, so we have Simon, Richard’s cousin, who is about as subtle as a pantomime villain wearing a badge that says EVIL.

He’s joined by Richard’s ex-girlfriend Sophia, who also wants to become queen. Maybe there are very few other career opportunities available to women in Aldovia. Together, they plot to expose Richard’s adoption and prevent him from inheriting the throne, which is all very dramatic if you’ve never watched a film before.

The trouble with A Christmas Prince is that absolutely nothing happens that you couldn’t have predicted within the first ten minutes. Every character behaves exactly as expected, every plot development arrives precisely on schedule and every supposed twist is so heavily signposted that you could see it coming from another fictional European country.

The handsome prince is secretly wonderful. The evil cousin is evil. The ex-girlfriend is horrible. The plucky heroine is rewarded for behaving appallingly. It’s like someone fed every Christmas romance ever made into a computer and asked it to produce the most beige film imaginable.

A Christmas prince: Still

A Christmas miracle! Or convenient paperwork

Eventually, Amber’s deception is exposed, Richard discovers she’s been lying to him and is understandably furious. She returns to New York looking miserable, and for one brief, glorious moment I thought the film might actually allow her to experience the consequences of her actions. I’ve found I quite enjoy that.

Perhaps she’ll lose her job? Maybe Richard will tell her to piss off (understandable)? Perhaps she’ll have a quiet moment of reflection about her ethics?

Haha, just kidding, obviously not.

It turns out that Richard’s late father had secretly changed the rules of succession, meaning Richard can inherit the throne despite being adopted! How sneaky. And happily, the evidence has conveniently been left behind for Amber to discover.

Amber saves the day, Richard becomes king and all is forgiven, despite the fact that she has spent most of the film behaving like someone who should be banned from entering the country.

And then, we’ve not quite exhausted every romantic cliché, Richard follows Amber back to New York and proposes. Why wouldn’t you marry the woman who lied to you, infiltrated your family home, deceived your little sister and almost published confidential information about your parentage? If that’s not the foundation of a lasting marriage, I don’t know what is.

Still from A Christmas Prince: Amber

Even Netflix worried about the viewers of this film

Perhaps the most entertaining thing about A Christmas Prince was that back in December 2017, Netflix famously tweeted: “To the 53 people who’ve watched A Christmas Prince every day for the past 18 days: Who hurt you?”

Netflix tweet about a christmas prince

Fifty-three people watched this film every single day for eighteen days. EIGHTEEN DAYS. I can only assume they were being held hostage, because having watched it once almost a year ago, I cannot imagine voluntarily subjecting myself – or anyone, frankly, except the guy that drives his motorbike up my road every morning at 6am – to it again.

I can understand rewatching a favourite Christmas film. There are films I happily return to every December because they’re funny, comforting or genuinely lovely (NB: Those films are: The Muppet Christmas Carol. OK, it’s one film). But this? Every day? For nearly three weeks? Were they hoping the ending might change? Were they studying Amber’s journalism techniques? Did they simply lose the remote control?

And yet this film was popular enough to spawn A Christmas Prince: The Royal Wedding and A Christmas Prince: The Royal Baby. I sincerely hope someone has thought to improve palace security in the meantime. I am not going to watch to check I’m afraid.

A Christmas Prince: The verdict

A Christmas Prince isn’t the worst Christmas film I’ve ever seen, that accolade still belonging squarely to I Believe In Santa, but it’s certainly one of the least interesting. There’s a bit of snow, some Christmas decorations, a palace, a handsome-if-you’re-into-that-kind-of-thing prince and the obligatory romantic ending, but precious little humour, chemistry or anything original.

The acting is perfectly adequate, the scenery is pretty enough and the whole thing is entirely inoffensive, provided you don’t have strong feelings about journalistic standards, child safeguarding or the constitutional legitimacy of fictional European monarchies.

But it’s also quite boring. Not hilariously terrible like A Very British Christmas, not entertainingly ridiculous like Hot Frosty, just relentlessly predictable, with all the excitement of completing a compulsory online training module while someone plays Christmas music in the background.

It’s the cinematic equivalent of a sprout curry: technically seasonal, faintly Christmassy, but leaving you unsure why anyone thought this was a good idea.

Rating: 4/10. A little bit festive, quite boring and absolutely not worth committing several crimes for.

More from my Christmas Film Review Endurance Test: If you haven’t suffered enough, you can also browse all my Christmas film reviews for more festive nonsense.

If you enjoyed this and you want more, help me afford Netflix here.

You can also see my Amazon wish list here.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top